AI vs Pro Designer: Focus Group Results Shocked Us

ai_tools ✗ QC Failed qc_failed
⭐ 8.3
Quality Score
17.1 MB
File Size
Apr 26, 2026
Created
#43
Script ID
• caption_word_coverage: Caption missing words from voiceover: 42% coverage (need ≥90%). Missing: people, judged, blind, nine, chose, set, as, more, modern, trustworthy, but, alpha, wasn, beaten, on, talent, were, speed, bias, is, trained, top, point, one, percent, of, dribbble, behance, so, its, output, literally, clusters, around, humans, already, voted, beautiful, it, aesthetic, arbitrage, real, edge, lives, in, strategy, narrative, cohesion, knowing, when, to, break, rules, has, perfect, taste, zero, context, move, use, generate, at, volume, human, creative, direction, make, mean, something, wins, 2025, save, this, you, ll, need, before, your, next, pitch

We gave a focus group brand assets — half made by AI, half by a $150-an-hour designer. They couldn't tell the difference. Here's what that actually means. Same brief for both: logo, color palette, hero banner, full typography system for a wellness startup. AI side used Looka for logo structure, Midjourney v6 with a brand-specific prompt, and Adobe Firefly for asset consistency. Designer side — 8 y…